[RECIPE] Amish-Style Soft Pretzels

2 mins read

I live less than 30 minutes from Philadelphia which, according to official rules, makes me a Philadelphian. It’s because of this close proximity that I totally get to claim the city’s food as my own and that includes the venerable soft pretzel. Now I know what you’re probably imagining–the kind of pretzels you get from some loud, bombastic street hawker selling pretzels at some sketchy roadside food cart–but you’re wrong. (By the way, those sketchy food carts are kinda awesome.)

If you’re not familiar with the Amish, they’re pretty much master bakers (and master quilters…and master builders) and in my corner of the world, they’re quite famous for their pretzels. Slightly crispy on the outside with a soft and chewy inside, they get a healthy sprinkling of salt and brushed (sometimes fully submerged) in melted butter. The result is a delightfully salty, greasy mess. I take every opportunity to grab one (or three) when I’m at my local farmers market or the famous Miller’s Twist at Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia.

I never knew how easy they were to replicate at home. Try this recipe and you may never purchase another store-bought pretzel again.

INGREDIENTS

FOR THE PRETZELS
2 ¼ tsp active dry yeast (1 standard packet)
1 cup warm water
1 tbs unsalted butter, melted
1 tsp sugar
1 tsp salt
3 cups all-purpose flour + up to ¾ cup more if needed
FOR THE PRETZEL BATH
2 cups water
4 tbs baking soda
1 tbs coarse salt, for sprinkling on top (or pretzel salt like this)
FOR FINISHING THE PRETZELS
6 tbs salted butter, melted

DIRECTIONS

Preheat oven to 475 degrees and line a large baking sheet or two baking sheets with parchment paper.

Combine yeast with warm water and sugar in the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with hook attachment. Once mixture becomes “frothy,” the yeast is ready. Stir in salt and 1 tbs of melted butter. Add flour 1 cup at a time until a dough forms and is no longer sticky. You may need more or less depending on temperature differences. If you press your finger into the dough and it bounces back, it’s ready to knead. Knead dough for 5 more minutes until smooth and pliable. Form dough into a ball and place it back into the bowl to rest for 15 minutes; cover with a tea towel. During this time, prepare the baking soda bath.

In a medium sized pot, boil 2 cups of water with 4 tbs of baking soda. Once the baking soda is mostly dissolved, take mixture off heat and allow it to come down to a lukewarm temperature. Pour into a 9×9 baking dish once cooled down.

At this time, 15 minutes of dough resting time should be up. Take dough out of the bowl and flatten slightly with the palm of your hand. Cut dough into 8 sections (like logs). Roll each log into a long rope, about 19-20 inches long. Shape dough into pretzel shape and place in baking soda bath for 10-20 seconds. If the whole pretzel isn’t covered by the water, spoon it on top of the areas is doesn’t reach. Once the time is up, carefully pick pretzel up either by your hand or with the help of a spatula and place on prepared baking sheet. You may have to re-shape slightly. Sprinkle the pretzel with coarse salt while still wet (optional). Repeat these steps until all 8 pretzels are prepared and on the baking sheet(s).

Bake pretzels for 8-9 minutes or until golden brown. Immediately from the oven, brush (heavily) with 6 tbs of melted butter.

These homemade soft pretzels are best served hot and fresh out of the oven but will keep for about 2 days stored at room temperature in an airtight container. A few seconds in the microwave and they’re good as new!

Food + travel writer | Author of Food Lovers' Guide to Philadelphia and Main Squeeze: Juicing Recipes for Your Healthiest Self

9 Comments

  1. I would just google gluten free amish pretzels and poke around to see what recipe looks best for you but honestly, none of them quite look like the ones from my recipe. I am not sure if you HAVE to do it in this shape I ve never seen them any other way, so maybe there is a reason for it. I think one thing about it is that they ll stay together better but you could maybe try doing short pretzel rods or something.

  2. Easy to make – lovely dough. The baking soda flavour was quite pronouced though, and I found it off-putting. Suggestions?

    • Thanks for the input, Linda–I suppose I’m a weirdo because I like the baking soda taste. 🙂 There are baking soda-free recipes, but the pretzels will lack the crispiness. (To combat that, some people put the finished pretzels under the broiler for a few seconds.)

  3. Just made a half batch of these. They turned out fairly well though not exactly like Miller’s Twist so I’ll keep experimenting. The only modification we made was not to meet the pretzels sit in the baking soda bath for two minutes. Every other recipe I checked advised to keep the bath brief so the dough didn’t absorb too much. Result was a lovely fluffy chew inside and brown crispy exterior. Yum

    • I really do need to modify this recipe because, after making these several times, I found that a quick 10-15 second dip/wash in the baking soda solution was sufficient enough to yield that deliciously crisp exterior.

      Thanks for the reminder! 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

About

Welcome to PALATE, your ultimate destination for the modern woman with a passion for food, travel, and lifestyle content. We're here to inspire and provide you with curated culinary experiences, breathtaking travel destinations, and empowering lifestyle stories.

Follow Us

Most Popular

Popular

Authors

Previous Story

[RECIPE] Braised Chicken Thighs: The Ultimate Comfort Dish

Next Story

[RECIPE] Grab & Go Granola Bars

Latest from Blog

New York City’s Hottest Drink is…Illegal

The most sought-after cocktail in New York City is not available in any bar. It’s an unlicensed street drink whose creator, a local entrepreneur, is looking to go legit. I caught up with Amseshem Foluke to get the whole story… The day had barely dawned, but the phone’s alarm wailed,…
Sexmuseum Amsterdam

Unusual Museums Around the World

I’ve always been drawn to obscure things; I’ve never been attracted to the normal or what the cool kids were doing. In particular, I enjoy the unusual and the macabre—blame it on an enduring love of the works of Edgar Allan Poe—and I always seem to seek out bizarre and…

10 Things to Do in Havana, Cuba

For most Americans born after the 1958 embargo, Cuba has remained an island of mystery even though it’s only 105 miles off the shore of Key West, Florida. We know very little of Cuba–perhaps only the 3 c’s–Communism, cars, and cigars, but the destination is so much more than that. The island is…
Beautifect Box makeup case

The Best Luxury Makeup Case for Travel

When it comes to traveling, maintaining your beauty routine can often feel like a daunting task. Limited space, rushed schedules, and varying lighting conditions can make it challenging to achieve that flawless look you desire. However, fear not, because Beautifect has revolutionized the way you can bring your beauty essentials…
GoUp